Sunday Gathering - John 6 : 16-21 - Erica Lugg - Sermon Only
Ep. 15

Sunday Gathering - John 6 : 16-21 - Erica Lugg - Sermon Only

•

Episode description

Erica Lugg takes the disciples’ crossing of the Sea of Galilee as a picture of the place she calls “between shores” — far enough from the destination that it seems unreachable, far enough from the shore they left that going back feels just as impossible, and making no progress in between. She is careful about the geography: these were experienced fishermen, the crossing was only five to eight miles, and in normal weather it was a few hours’ work. Yet John says it was already dark when they set out, and Matthew puts Jesus’ arrival at the fourth watch, somewhere between three and six in the morning — meaning they had been rowing against the wind most of the night and covered three or four miles. Her point is that the dark place is not evidence that Jesus is absent; it may be precisely where he intends to reveal himself.

Obedience, she insists, does not buy us calm water. Jesus had told them to get in the boat and cross, and the storm came anyway, because obedience sometimes takes us into places where we cannot see. She tells a story about Aidan, her eldest, then three years old, walking home from nursery with Nick when a thunderstorm broke. Aidan sat down in the road and refused to move, and they were drenched — the point being that sitting down in the middle feels like a reasonable option, but you always get wetter doing nothing than letting your legs keep going. Jesus, she notices, let them struggle for a long time before he came, and that was deliberate: he had something to show them that they could not have seen in easy water. She is honest about the questions that arrive in that gap — where are you, God? — and answers them with promise rather than feeling: he said he would be with us to the end of the age, and feelings are not the truth.

When Jesus does come, John’s word is “suddenly”, and Lugg makes much of it: the suddenly of God rarely announces itself. The storm they had been fighting to control is the surface he walks on, and she draws the distinction sharply — her instinct is to manage a situation, to fix it and box it, but Jesus does not manage the storm, he rules over it. His words, “It is I; do not be afraid”, are the words of the burning bush, the divine name, so this is a revelation of identity rather than a cheery reassurance from across the water. That is why “do not be afraid” can carry weight at all. Their peace, she says, was not found in the weather changing; John never actually says the storm stopped, only that they reached the other side. The turning point was a change of heart — from fear to surrender, from striving to trust — and it came when they were willing to take him into the boat, which is a different thing from wanting him to sort out the storm while we keep hold of the tiller. She closes by inviting the congregation to give the wind and the waves to Jesus as an act of worship rather than waiting for every question to be answered.

Bible passages

  • John 6:16-21 — the crossing and the walking on water, the sermon text
  • John 6:18 — the sea grew rough because a strong wind was blowing
  • Matthew 14:22-33 — the parallel account, source of the “fourth watch of the night” detail
  • Exodus 3:14 — “I am who I am”, the name spoken at the burning bush
  • Matthew 28:20 — “I am with you always, to the very end of the age”
  • John 14:6 — “I am the way, the truth and the life”
  • John 6:1-15 — last week’s feeding of the five thousand, whose point about Philip she returns to

Key points

  • The dark place is not evidence that Jesus is absent
  • Obedience takes us into storms rather than around them
  • Seasoned fishermen, a short crossing, and still no progress all night
  • Between shores: the destination out of reach, going back equally far, giving up feels sensible
  • Aidan sitting down in the rain: you get wetter doing nothing
  • Jesus let them struggle for a long time, because he had something to show them
  • “Where are you, God?” is answered by his promise, not by our feelings
  • How much of life is lived with no expectation that God will intervene?
  • “Suddenly”: God breaks in unannounced
  • Jesus does not manage the storm, he rules over it
  • “I am” is the divine name, so this is revelation, not reassurance
  • “Do not be afraid” only carries weight because of who says it
  • Peace came from the revelation, not from the storm ending
  • They were willing to take him into the boat: surrender, not merely rescue
  • John never says the storm stopped; the change was in them

Calls to action

  • Bring the storm you are in to Jesus, and recognise who he is in it
  • Stop managing what only he can rule over
  • Willingly receive him into your boat, not just his help from a distance
  • Surrender the control, not only the circumstances
  • Choose worship over worry and striving, before anything changes
  • If you do not yet know who Jesus is, look at him and see

Watch the video: https://youtu.be/NcyWEcuO4qU

Download transcript (.vtt)
0:00

in the middle of this. But the dark place that you are in, if that is where you are today, is not

0:06

evidence that Jesus is absent. Maybe it's the very place where he intends to reveal himself to you

0:14

more clearly, which is what we see towards the end of the story. I've written this down as number two,

0:21

second point, but like I said, I don't know. Verse 18 says, the sea became rough because a strong wind

0:26

was blowing surely if Jesus is involved and surely if we are being obedient to his word

0:33

surely that will mean in this life there won't be storms surely that that will mean that there

0:39

will be easy waters well we know all we all know the answer to that obedience to Jesus does mean

0:45

that he will take us into places where we feel uncertain and we can't see obedience to Jesus

0:50

will sometimes take us into places where it feels like we are up against a storm the gale starts

0:56

to blow around us and the wind and the waves become choppy. To get a bit of an idea of this

1:03

story I want us to think back to Matthew's gospel and I've put the timeline together. So the journey

1:08

across the Sea of Galilee should not have been difficult, these guys were experienced fishermen

1:14

so this wouldn't have been difficult for them. Depending on the route it would have been five

1:20

to eight miles that's all and in normal weather conditions it would have been completed in a

1:26

few hours. But John tells us it's already getting dark when they set out. Matthew says that Jesus

1:33

came to them during the fourth watch of the night, so somewhere between 3am and 6am, meaning

1:40

that they'd been battling the storm for most of the night. How many of you this morning feel like

1:49

you've been battling a storm for most of the night? Let's be honest here. Perhaps not even the night,

1:57

right toby a bit longer than a night maybe a week a month a year battling a storm this story gives

2:08

us this idea that this is wasn't just one moment in time this is wasn't a five minute battle this

2:14

was from the time it started to get dark till around three to six o'clock in the morning all

2:19

night intense battling most of the night and despite hours of rowing they had covered three

2:27

to four miles, leaving their destination so far ahead of them that it felt unreachable. And yet

2:34

when they looked back to the shore that they had come from, that would have felt like miles away

2:39

as well. How do you get there with all this wind and wave? The wind had slowed their progress to

2:45

almost nothing, turning what should have been a manageable crossing into an exhausting all-night

2:52

struggle in darkness and rough water and this is one of the hardest places for us to be in between

2:59

shores where the destination looks so far ahead we can't see we can't see the shoreline it's that

3:06

far it's dark the wind and the waves are raging against us and then when we look to the shore

3:11

because maybe it would be safer to go back and that looks equally as far away and we're now

3:15

suddenly sat between shores in this no man's land of no progress. Anybody identify with that

3:24

this morning? These were not inexperienced travellers, many of them fishermen who knew

3:30

the waters but hour after hour straining against the wind making no progress must have turned what

3:36

they had once decided was confidence into questions and probably fear. Maybe we identify with that

3:45

place this morning between shores the destination too far ahead the place we've come from too far

3:54

behind in this middle land wondering if what we had once been convinced was the voice of Jesus

4:00

really was his voice at all once sure about the direction and instruction we'd be given

4:06

only to find ourselves in a place of struggle and strain and pain the between shores where the

4:14

destination seems out of reach we're going back feels easier and we're giving up suddenly begins

4:21

to feel like an option it's really interesting but Nick mentioned that this morning that sometimes

4:27

and when I hear it and by the grace of God I don't want that for me sometimes it is easier

4:33

we feel just to stop in the middle of the between shores when Aidan was very little Aidan's our

4:39

eldest son he's 31 now but when he was about three years old Nick used to walk him to nursery

4:43

and the nursery school wasn't that far away

4:46

so it wasn't cruel.

4:48

He had to walk, it was good exercise.

4:49

It was far enough away to be a reasonable distance

4:52

for little three-year-old legs.

4:54

And on this one particular day,

4:55

Nick tells a story of how they were coming home from nursery

4:58

when suddenly the clouds began to gather

5:00

and there was a thunderstorm brewing.

5:03

And he was encouraging Jacob,

5:04

come on Jacob, come on,

5:06

oh sorry, not Jacob, Aidan, I forgot which child.

5:09

Come on Aidan, let's move faster

5:10

and his little legs were going

5:12

and then suddenly he just sat down and refused to go anywhere and the heavens opened and the

5:18

rain came down and Aidan and Nick completely drenched because Jacob, Aidan, because Aidan had

5:24

decided that the best option was to sit down and give in. Was that the best option? No, it was to

5:31

keep on going but we have that choice and sometimes we do feel like doing that, don't we? We do wonder

5:37

where is God in all of this? And the temptation to sit down in the middle always feels like a

5:43

reasonable option. But let me tell you something, you will always get far wetter sitting, doing

5:49

nothing than you will letting your legs keep going, keep going, keep going. So for the disciples this

5:55

was prolonged strain. It wasn't one terrifying moment, it was hour after hour of fighting

6:01

resistance. By the time Jesus comes to them in this miraculous sign walking on water, they are

6:07

exhausted, they are frustrated, they are disorientated, and they are far from either shore, in between

6:14

shores, in this no man's land. And one thing that I've noticed is that Jesus let them struggle

6:23

for a long time before he appeared. Praise the Lord. How does that feel? Because we live in an

6:35

instant world, well in actual fact when we've been struggling with something for a while, we want

6:39

Jesus to come through for us but in this situation Jesus let them it was in his plan because he had

6:47

something that he wanted to show them something that he wanted them to see that they would not

6:53

have seen had they not been in the dark in a storm battling for an extended period of time

7:01

this is incredible what is so amazing that Jesus wants to show you this morning that he will allow

7:07

you to go through struggle and strain, times of uncertainty and insecurity, what does he want to

7:14

show you? What does he want to show me? Questions that I am familiar with in my own times of struggle

7:23

and I say them, I try not to say them but I do say them, things like where God, where are you in this?

7:29

Well of course he's there, isn't he? How do I know? How do I know that God is with me? Because what?

7:40

Because he promised.

7:41

Yeah, but I don't feel it, Gerald.

7:45

Sorry, Erica.

7:47

Sorry, Erica.

7:48

Sorry that you don't feel it.

7:49

It's his promise.

7:51

The reason I don't need to say, God, where are you in this,

7:54

is because he's promised me that he's right there.

7:56

Yeah, but I don't feel it.

7:58

Let me tell you something this morning, that feelings are not the truth.

8:02

We have to recognize them and we have to see them for what they are.

8:05

But Jesus comes and he says, I am with you.

8:08

In fact, I am with you to the very end of the age.

8:10

in fact I was with you yesterday I'm with you today and I'm with you forever but in times of

8:16

confusion this no man's land I can hear myself saying God where are you and he says well I'm

8:21

right here because I never went anywhere why can't I hear you Lord well because I gave you an

8:26

instruction already I told you to get in the boat and go to the other side the promise was that we

8:31

were going to get to the other side but I can't hear you yeah well I've told you told you what to

8:37

do. And I can hear the disciples going through this in their mind. Jesus, God, Jesus, where are

8:43

you in all of this? Why can't we hear you? One of the things that I was so pleased with that Liz

8:49

said last week, she said that, remember she said about how Jesus said to Philip, how are we going

8:56

to feed all these people? Do you remember this bit? And it wasn't because Jesus didn't know how

9:01

to feed all these people. He was testing Philip to see if Philip had any expectation that God would

9:06

intervene. And the question that I went away with last week is, Erica, how much of life do you live

9:12

with zero expectation that God will intervene? How much? How much of your life do you live with

9:24

an expectation that Jesus will intervene? It might be a struggle and it might be dark and there might

9:31

be wind and rain, but Jesus has always got a plan. God has always got a plan. And surely that is a

9:39

hallelujah moment people he's always got a plan and Jesus did have a glorious plan one that they

9:47

would never have experienced if they'd not encountered the dark and if they'd not found

9:51

themselves between shores still with me point number something verse 19 says after the wind

10:03

and the rain comes they had rowed three or four miles when suddenly they saw Jesus walking on the

10:08

water toward the boat. Suddenly, what a great word. The suddenly of God rarely arrives with

10:15

warning. It always comes unannounced and unexpected. One moment the disciples are straining

10:22

at the oars. One moment they are exhausted and frustrated, convinced that nothing is changing

10:28

and then suddenly Jesus comes to them walking on the water. And that's often the way God moves.

10:38

suddenly heaven breaks into our moment of darkness without announcement. It might be a conversation,

10:47

a breakthrough, a place that was not, a peace that was not there before, an answer, a revelation,

10:52

a walking on the water, a miraculous sign, anything at all. Suddenly God breaks into our moments

10:59

unannounced and unexpected. Suddenly they saw Jesus walking on the water toward the boat.

11:06

the very thing that they were battling to control the very thing that had caused

11:12

them fear and anxiety Jesus takes authority over isn't that incredible you know what my instinct

11:20

is to do is to manage I love managing stuff because I like to fix things and have it in nice

11:26

little neat boxes and know well this circumstance has arrived and so what I'm going to do is manage

11:32

it. I'm sure if I'd have been in that boat that day I'd have been managing people. I think if we

11:37

row like this and I think if we head towards that way and maybe if we adjust ourselves I would have

11:42

been managing I'm sure. My instinct in my situations is to manage the situation but Jesus doesn't

11:49

manage the storm, he rules over it and that's the difference between me trying to survive

11:56

and his sovereignty over my life they were rowing harder adjusting sails fighting wind trying to

12:05

stay afloat everything they did was reactive the storm controlling their actions and probably their

12:12

feelings but Jesus comes walking on the top of the thing that threatens them he is lord even over the

12:18

things that seem out of control to us yeah but I don't feel it feelings are not the truth he is the

12:29

truth, the way, the truth, and the life. The waves that were exhausting the disciples are beneath his

12:35

feet. The storm overwhelming them is under his authority. He is the boss of them. Oh, gosh. He's

12:52

the boss. He's the boss of the wind and the waves. He's the boss of the darkness. He owns it all.

13:00

And as I was preparing this this morning, well, not this morning, but as I was preparing this,

13:03

this morning I looked at that statement he is the boss and I thought I wonder what it feels like to

13:08

actually begin to speak to my circumstances and actually say let me just remind you who's the boss

13:13

Jesus is the boss of them verse 20 says it is I Jesus comes towards them saying it's I

13:22

do not be afraid and I believe that this is the turning point of the story

13:26

in John this is far more than Jesus coming up and going hey guys hi guys it's me Jesus in case you

13:34

are wondering who's coming across the water, standing on the river water, you know, it's just

13:38

me, Jesus, you know, hi, how you doing? That sounds really, really fluffy. He comes to them and he uses

13:45

the very words that he used when he spoke to Moses in the burning bush. In the Jewish mind,

13:53

those were the words God used when he revealed himself to Moses. I am who I am. Before you,

14:00

I was there, before the world I existed, my voice put the wind and the rain in place, it was my voice

14:10

that created the oceans, before when everything was dark and formless I existed, before you existed

14:17

I existed, before your problems ever existed I existed, I am, I am sovereign, I am the one that

14:24

is eternal I existed before existence even existed I am sovereign God the one who is not

14:31

controlled by circumstance darkness or chaos and so when Jesus said to them I am do not be afraid

14:38

he's not merely identifying himself as hey guys it's Jesus because that sounds really fluffy

14:43

he's revealing himself as God the God that Moses encountered at the burning bush is now standing

14:52

on the waves this is revelation moment in the darkness in the middle of the chaos in the middle

14:59

of the storm Jesus is revealing not only his presence but his identity and John wants us to

15:06

understand that the one standing on the waves Toby I want to encourage you this morning because I know

15:11

you're going through some stuff with your job right I want to encourage you that the one standing

15:16

on the waves of your circumstance is not merely a teacher or a miracle worker or a prophet but he

15:22

is the divine son of God and he says to you today I am do not be afraid I am do not be afraid I'm

15:31

not I'm not here to fix things tweak things I am the God of all creation and I come to you in the

15:36

darkness and in the storm and I remind you I am who I am guys don't be afraid don't be afraid

15:46

yeah I know but you don't know my circumstance he existed before your circumstance he existed

15:54

long before time he's existed before matter he's sovereign and he comes to you on the waves and

16:01

says do not be afraid I really want to encourage you with that I feel quite emotional Toby I want

16:07

to encourage you with that don't be afraid I am who I am he's revealing himself this is revelation

16:14

moment. And John wants us to understand that we're not talking about a teacher or a miracle worker,

16:19

we're talking about the divine son of God. And that changes everything about the next phrase,

16:25

do not be afraid. That command is rooted in revelation. If you do not know who Jesus is,

16:31

let me tell you now, you will live your life afraid of everything. When you know who Jesus is,

16:38

that he's not just a great teacher and he's not just the miracle worker, that he is the God of

16:43

the universe that word do not be afraid no longer sounds glib does it it sounds earthy it sounds

16:50

something that we can build our life upon rooted in revelation and Jesus is not asking you to

16:57

pretend that the storm is not real he's showing them that fear loses authority when you recognize

17:03

who Jesus is comes walking towards you in the wind and the waves lost my place but it doesn't

17:11

really matter. Their peace is not found in the storm disappearing immediately, but in the

17:17

revelation that it's the sovereign God who stands in the middle with them. We want Jesus to take

17:22

away the storms like that. It doesn't happen. Sometimes it does, but my experience is sometimes

17:27

it doesn't. But my anchor is not the wind and the waves, and whether they're there, my anchor is

17:34

Jesus. Verse 21 says, then they were willing to take him into the boat.

17:43

We spend so much of life wanting Jesus to deal with the chaos and the storms

17:47

while still wanting to keep control of the boat ourselves.

17:51

I'm just preaching to myself this morning.

17:54

I love it when Jesus does amazing things.

17:56

I love it when he comes through for me.

17:58

I love all those things.

17:59

But there's a part of me that likes to keep control of the boat itself.

18:03

And I don't believe I'm the only person in here.

18:06

Thanks, Mireille.

18:07

It's just me and you, the rest of them.

18:08

They're all good.

18:10

Rob's nodding, yeah.

18:11

I noticed that.

18:13

This wasn't just anyone getting to the boat.

18:17

Once they recognized who he was,

18:19

they willingly received him

18:20

into the place of struggle, fear, and limitation.

18:24

What do we do when we have a revelation

18:26

of who Jesus truly is?

18:28

Do we resist?

18:30

Do we want the miracle worker that stands on the edge

18:33

and kind of looks at our lives from a distance

18:35

and kind of throws best wishes in or good actions in?

18:39

Or do we actually surrender to him and say,

18:41

Lord please come and get into my boat and help me to navigate the storm. John's gospel unlike the

18:49

other two never actually tells us that the storm stops it doesn't say that it just says that they

18:55

get to the other side because I believe that John's gospel the light of the revelation of Jesus is what

19:01

stops that sorry the light of the revelation of Jesus the storm no longer exists. So the turning

19:10

point for them was not necessarily a change in the weather, but a change in their heart.

19:15

From fear to surrender, stopping striving to trust, stopping taking control, but allowing

19:21

God to step in. And for many of us, that's the real challenge of the storm. Not simply

19:26

whether circumstances change immediately. I'd love to say this morning that everything

19:30

is going to go back to diddly-do, everything is going to be fine. We don't know that, but

19:35

we do know the one who is Lord over it all. Charles Spurgeon, and I think this quote is

19:41

attributed to him, said this. He says, I've learned to kiss the wave that slams me into

19:48

the rock of ages. Shall I say that again? I've learned to kiss the wave that slams me

19:56

into the rock of ages. At the discipleship course this week, the first clip of the video

20:01

that they showed was a man a pastor from Syria Serbia sorry from Serbia and he says that he said

20:10

I wish persecution on the church in the west well that sounds a bit mean doesn't it

20:19

but then he goes on to explain why and he says that when we face those things it teaches us to

20:29

lean into the sweetness of Jesus the storm the darkness those situations we can't control

20:37

those things teach us to lean into the sweetness of Jesus and maybe the very storm that the

20:46

disciples feared became the place where they encountered a deeper revelation of who Jesus

20:52

really is and I pray that for our lives maybe today Jesus is not asking you to row harder

21:00

maybe he's asking you to recognize him trust him and willingly receive him into the middle of your

21:07

storm that you have been trying to manage on your own what would it look like to stop striving for

21:14

control and surrender and instead to trust his sovereignty some of us have spent so much time

21:21

staring at the waves that we've forgotten to look for the one walking toward us and the greatest

21:27

miracle in this story is not that Jesus walked on water, but it is that frightened, exhausted

21:35

disciples discovered who was standing before them. Let me say that line again. The greatest miracle

21:43

in this story is not that Jesus walked on water. Of course he did. He's God. Maybe the miracle

21:53

for my life for your life is that frightened exhausted disciples discover who is really

22:01

standing before them and maybe that is where worship begins not when every storm has settled

22:10

not when every answer has been question has been answered but when our eyes are lifted again

22:16

to the one who stands sovereign above the chaos and the one who comes towards us in the dark

22:23

saying i am do not be afraid i'm going to ask the musicians to um just come and play for us

22:31

as i was preparing this i could have gone down the route of a response where we

22:50

invite you forward to so that we can pray for you for the wind and the waves in your life and

22:55

the struggle and i don't really feel that i want to do that this morning because i know that god

23:03

already sees those things he already sees what you're going through he already knows that you're

23:08

in a dark place he already knows that there are wind and waves he already knows that and so I

23:16

don't want us to respond necessarily to those things although I'm really happy to pray for you

23:21

afterwards I'm really happy to do that but I just wondered if we could respond by kind of shifting

23:30

our sorry impression of him that maybe what we could do this morning is actually to give the

23:45

wind and the waves to him and the storms and those dark places and anything else that you're going

23:49

through actually just begin to give them to him as an act of worship so I'm going to ask the musicians

24:01

to play and I really believe that Jesus wants to reveal himself to you this morning saying I can't

24:15

see Jesus I don't know who he is I can't recognize him a prayer is that you would see Jesus this

24:22

morning there's an old hymn that says when things that surround me become shadows in the light of

24:28

you I worship you Jesus and what we need is that fresh view of Jesus so that those things that have

24:36

crept in and have and have taken focus and we've become fixated on because they are so real and so

24:42

near that when those things that surround us become shadows in the light of who Jesus is and if that's

24:55

your prayer this morning help me to see you Lord more clearly in this storm help me to recognize

25:00

you in the darkness, help me to trust you, relinquish control, help me to see you as you

25:06

truly are, God of all creation, therefore God of my situation. If that's you this morning I just

25:12

want to encourage you to stand with me and I'm going to pray. Jesus for so many of us the storm

25:45

has become so loud that we've lost sight of who you are and we've spent so much energy trying to

25:54

manage what only you can rule over and we've strained at the oars trying to hold everything

26:03

together in our own strength but today we choose to lift our eyes towards you again

26:11

and I choose worship over worry and striving and control. I choose worship. Thank you that you come

26:25

toward us in the darkness. Thank you that you are not absent in the storm. Thank you that the waves

26:31

overwhelming us are already beneath your feet. And Lord, just as the disciples willingly received

26:38

you into the boat, we choose to willingly receive you again in the middle of our circumstances.

26:45

We surrender again, not just the storm, but the control, not just the fear or the striving,

27:04

not just the outcome, we surrender ourselves. And as we offer ourselves now to you in worship,

27:14

this isn't escapism this isn't emotional it's not denial worship is our declaration that you are

27:21

greater than the storm worship is our choice to fix our eyes on the one standing above the waves

27:29

father this morning before anything changes around us we choose worship before every question is

27:40

answered we choose worship before the storm settles we choose worship because you are still

27:48

the great I am the eternal one the sovereign one the God who was and who is and always will be

27:55

the one who stands above the chaos and comes towards us in love this morning we choose worship

28:04

and I wonder church if we could stand together and just just begin to worship just give it

28:14

all to him, everything, just give it to him in worship.